Biggovernment.com reports~
Yet one of the nation’s top surgeons, with credibility and acclaim the world over for the pioneering surgeries he has and his personal story of overcoming hardship, recently ripped the dominant health care legislation before Congress in a critique similar to that of conservatives and libertarians. Benjamin Carson, director of pediatric neurosurgery at the Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions in Baltimore, Md., and recipient of numerous awards including the Presidential Medal of Freedom, criticized in a recent interview the approach of the current bills for their mandate, creation of a “public option,” and lack of malpractice liability reform.
“My biggest problem is I feel it’s going in the wrong direction,” Carson told reporters at TV station WLOS in Asheville, N.C. “It’s giving us more government and less autonomy. And I think we should be going in exactly the opposite direction. We should be having more autonomy and less government. And that is the kind of thing that brings the prices down.”
[...]
Carson also blasted proposals backed by Obama and most Democrats that would create a government-backed “public option,” saying it would inevitably lead to a “single payer” system like that of Canada, in which the government as the sole insurer would end up calling all the shots for patients. He pointed to how the Canadian government itself crowded out private insurance. “What happened to the private insurance companies in Canada? Just like that, they were gone, because they couldn’t compete with it (the government). Now, why would it be any different here? That’s one of the things that disappoints me about the lack of honesty … We can’t really debate when there’s all this subterfuge.”
Carson said that despite the problems with American health care, Canada and European countries were not models to emulate in their health insurance financing systems. “All we have to do is go to other places and see what’s going on. See how long people have to wait. Very, very long waiting periods. Why do you think so many people from Canada come here when they have a problem? I know a young man in England who has a problem with his knee. He needs an operation, and the waiting list is so long. … These are the kind of things that people in this country are not used to. But more importantly, it’s something that we don’t have to get used to. We can fix this without going to that kind of system that causes those kinds of long waits.”
As his main “fix”, Carson proposes a system of patient empowerment in which “individuals and families can own their own insurance; it doesn’t have to be through their employer.” Not all of Carson’s ideas expressed in the interview were free-market, though. He did propose that the government set insurance rates, and cover patients’ catastrophic costs above $250,000. (more…)
Video link to the interview here.
h/t:blackelectorate.com


4 Comments
Permalink
Oh.
My.
Permalink
Informer, Dr. Benjamin makes some good points. I respect his opinion as a expert in the field. But the current Obamacare proposal, as you call it, is not similar to any other nations healthcare. Our system is still an employee based system, whtich is unique. That said the Max Baucus proposal is a disaster waiting to happen. Mandate everyone get care, while subsidizing those who can’t afford it, while insurance companies charge what they may. How can the insurance lobby not love that idea? I do love the elimination of preexisting conditions, and customers not being dropped from their healthcare when it is most needed. This is the only thing I like in the bill.
We will not get no real reform on healthcare, because the lobby is too strong. The dems are weak and divided, the Reps. are too busy saying no to everything in order to destroy Obama and seize power next year.
That’s america for you…..
Permalink
Wouldn’t bother me one bit if this man were Surgeon General for LIFE.
Wow, I needed to hear that particular opinion of the situation.
Too bad cameraman man had a frenetic fail near the end.
The whole interview was analogous to watching a kick returner running it back for 103 yards while throwing out a few stiff-arms for good measure!
Permalink
Its good for the brotha to be well reknown in his field of work, however he is in the minority(no pun intended) when it comes to the public option aspect of the health care reform. Insurance companies NEED competition to keep the prices down and fair. As of now, the price increases simply cannot be justified, unless you include the “greed factor”. I have seen my premiums rise over 75% in 3 years,with no additional services added. What occupation and in what industry does the pay of the average citizen match that type of increase? Why should the insurance industry receive as much as 33% simply for administrative costs? How much does it cost to push papers around and make decisions?